Madison, Wisconsin, isn’t just about cheese curds and craft beer (though, let’s be honest, those are pretty great, too). It’s also home to a deep-rooted tradition that turns every Friday into a culinary celebration: the fish fry. This isn’t just any fish dinner; it’s an institution, a way of life, and a delicious dive into Wisconsin’s foodie culture. Ready to explore the coolest spots for snagging that crispy, golden goodness? Let’s reel in the best places Madison has to offer for an unforgettable fish fry experience.

The Old Fashioned: Where Tradition Meets Taste

Perched on the edge of Capitol Square, The Old Fashioned isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a tribute to all things Wisconsin. Their fish fry? Legendary. Picture this: beer-battered fish that’s so crispy, you can hear it crackle, paired with the creamiest coleslaw, golden fries, and rye bread. It’s a dish that commands a weekly pilgrimage. And with a side of their Wisconsin-centric ambiance, you’re in for a treat that’s as much about the vibe as it is about the flavor.

Toby’s Supper Club: A Nostalgic Nod to Supper Club Culture

Step into Toby’s Supper Club, and you’re stepping back in time. This place oozes old-school charm and serves up a fish fry that’ll make you understand why Wisconsin supper clubs are the stuff of legend. Toby’s nails the classic fish fry formula: light, crispy batter, flaky fish, and sides that taste like home. It’s comfort food in a setting that feels like a warm hug—a must-visit for anyone looking to experience genuine Wisconsin hospitality.

Quivey’s Grove: A Historic Feast

Nestled in a picturesque historic farmhouse, Quivey’s Grove offers a fish fry with a side of history. Dining here feels like a page from a storybook, with beer-battered fish that’s as rich in flavor as the surroundings are in stories. The homemade tartar sauce and coleslaw are the perfect companions to this meal, making every bite a journey through Wisconsin’s culinary landscape. It’s a place where every dish tells a story, and the fish fry is the protagonist.

Avenue Club and the Bubble Up Bar: Retro Vibes, Modern Flavors

Avenue Club and the Bubble Up Bar shakes up the fish fry scene with its retro flair and innovative approach to this classic dish. Here, the fish fry struts a modern twist—think beer-battered brilliance or a lighter, pan-fried option for the contemporary palate. Paired with their signature cocktails, the Avenue Club offers a fish fry experience that’s as refreshing as it is satisfying. It’s the perfect spot for foodies looking for a side of cool with their crispy fish.

The Great Dane Pub & Brewing Co.: Craft Beers and Crispy Bites

With several locales dotting Madison, The Great Dane Pub & Brewing Co. is where laid-back atmosphere meets culinary craftsmanship. Their fish fry is a testament to their commitment to quality, offering a golden, beer-battered delight that pairs perfectly with their craft brews. It’s a place where friends gather, glasses clink, and the fish fry stands as a delicious testament to Wisconsin’s pub culture.

Madison’s fish fry scene is as diverse as it is delicious, offering something for every taste and temperament. From the nostalgia of supper clubs to the innovative twists of modern eateries, each spot on this list offers a unique take on a beloved tradition. So, whether you’re a lifelong Wisconsinite or a curious visitor, diving into Madison’s fish fry culture is a flavorful journey through the heart of the city’s culinary scene. Grab your friends, pick a spot, and get ready to experience the crispy, golden joy of a Madison fish fry. Happy feasting!

Fish Fry Finder Map